Home Blog Page 182

Medal of Honor Spotlight – Major Charles J. Watters, Chaplain

0
Medal of Honor Chaplain Charles Watters
Chaplains

Chaplains have been a part of the United States armed forces ever since Army chaplains put their lives on the line during the battles of Lexington and Concord in 1775. Their mission has always been to give spiritual aid as well as prayers and comfort for the military and bring spiritual peace to their flocks. But there have been many times they have led troops into battle, assisted the wounded, carried men from the battlefield, and lay beside them in trenches with enemy fire overhead.

Since the Civil War, when the first Medal s of Honor were awarded, there have only been nine chaplains who have received this highest honor paid to military. Seven of these were Army, one was Naval Reserve and one was Navy. Of the nine, two came from New York, six came from Massachusetts, Kansas, Illinois, Indiana and California.

One came from New Jersey.

Major Charles J. Watters

Meet Major Charles J. Watters, a Catholic priest from Jersey City, a graduate of Seton Hall University, and a major with the 173d Airborne Brigade of the US Army during the Vietnam War. He was born Jan. 17, 1927.

Fr. Watters was not the ordinary parish priest. He also held a commercial pilots’ license.

After graduating from Seton Hall, Father Watters went on to Immaculate Conception Seminary in Darlington, and was ordained a priest in 1953. Over the next few years, he served in parishes in Jersey City  Rutherford,  Cranford and Paramus in the Archdiocese of Newark., At the same time, intrigued by flying he studied and became certified as a commercial pilot. In 1962, he joined the New Jersey Air National Guard, and two years later, he signed on with the Army at Fort Dix, serving as a chaplain there.

Viet Nam

In 1966, the chaplain was assigned to the Republic of Vietnam serving with Company A, 173rd Support Battalion, 173rd Airborne Brigade. But Major Watters didn’t always stay with the support group. He frequently went with the brigade’s line units into the battlefield. Then, at the end of his 12 month tour, he requested and was granted an extension to stay with his men for another six months.

It was  November 1967.  The chaplain was with the 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry, and the men were involved in fighting for Hill 875 near Dak To. An intense fire fight broke out on Nov. 19. And men were dying on the battlefield.  So Chaplain Watters did what heroic chaplains do. He rushed onto the battlefield and began picking up the wounded and bringing them back to safety. Then he brought back those who had been killed. He administered the Last Rites of the Catholic Church to the dying and continued his mission of helping his soldiers on the front line.

The fighting and killing went on for hours, yet Chaplain Watters maintained his own composure, inspired his soldiers and continued his mission to help bring the fallen to safety.  He assisted medics with emergency care, he continued administering the last rites, he spurned every effort to stay behind the battle zone to protect himself. It was then he himself was wounded and died that day on Hill 875.

His heroism was not forgotten. Chaplain Charles Watters was the first Army chaplain to receive the Medal of Honor since the Civil War.  The U.S. Army Chaplain Center and School renamed its building Watters Hall.  Public School  24 in Jersey City was renamed Chaplain Charles J. Watters School.

The inscription of the Medal of Honor for Chaplain Major Charles Watters reads:

Citation

For conspicuous gallantry and intrepidity in action at the risk of his life above and beyond the call of duty. Chaplain Watters distinguished himself during an assault in the vicinity of Dak To. Chaplain Watters was moving with one of the companies when it engaged a heavily armed enemy battalion. As the battle raged and the casualties mounted, Chaplain Watters, with complete disregard for his safety, rushed forward to the line of contact. Unarmed and completely exposed, he moved among, as well as in front of the advancing troops, giving aid to the wounded, assisting in their evacuation, giving words of encouragement, and administering the last rites to the dying. When a wounded paratrooper was standing in shock in front of the assaulting forces, Chaplain Watters ran forward, picked the man up on his shoulders and carried him to safety. As the troopers battled to the first enemy entrenchment, Chaplain Watters ran through the intense enemy fire to the front of the entrenchment to aid a fallen comrade. A short time later, the paratroopers pulled back in preparation for a second assault. Chaplain Watters exposed himself to both friendly and enemy fire between the two forces in order to recover two wounded soldiers. Later, when the battalion was forced to pull back into a perimeter, Chaplain Watters noticed that several wounded soldiers were lying outside the newly formed perimeter. Without hesitation and ignoring attempts to restrain him, Chaplain Watters left the perimeter three times in the face of small arms, automatic weapons, and mortar fire to carry and to assist the injured troopers to safety. Satisfied that all of the wounded were inside the perimeter, he began aiding the medics … applying field bandages to open wounds, obtaining and serving food and water, giving spiritual and mental strength and comfort. During his ministering, he moved out to the perimeter from position to position redistributing food and water, and tending to the needs of his men. Chaplain Watters was giving aid to the wounded when he himself was mortally wounded. Chaplain Watters’ unyielding perseverance and selfless devotion to his comrades was in keeping with the highest traditions of the U.S. Army.

Presentation

The Medal of Honor was presented to the fallen chaplain’s family posthumously  by Vice President Spiro Agnew on Nov. 19, 1967.

Major Watters is buried in Arlington National Cemetery.

Also in this series

Thorne

Brief History

New Series

AAUW January Half Price Sale

0
Sale
MIDDLETOWN –

The ever popular January Half Price Sale offered by the AAUW (American Association of University Women) Northern Monmouth County Branch will be held Saturday, Jan. 28 from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.

The sale is held at the AAUW Book Store at the lower level of Old First Church, 69 Kings Highway.

Everything in the store will be half price throughout those hours, including hardcover and paperback books, CD’s, DVD’s, games, puzzles and a large assortment of children’s books.  Recent releases are excluded from the special sale..

Proceeds from the sale support scholarships for women at Brookdale Community College and Monmouth University.

The Book Sale is open Thursdays from 10:00 a.m. to  noon for sales as well as book donations. Regular hours for sales and donations continue  on Saturdays from 9:00 to 1:00 p.m. except holiday weekends.

For more information about AAUW, membership, Book Sale, and guidelines for tax deductible donations, visit the web site at  aauw-nj-nmcb.org or call 732-275-2237.

Previous stories here

Hazlet Strong

0

This is one very heartfelt message from the Hazlet Superintendent of Schools, Dr. Scott Ridley, Ed.D, addressed to the Hazlet Strong community and urging prayers for the family devastated by the recent house fire in Hazlet…

 

Good day Hazlet community. I would like to acknowledge the tremendous outpouring of support and good wishes for the Middle Road School family that suffered a tragic house fire last week.

There are no words, no playbook, no reaction that can lessen the horror of this catastrophe though if we remain Hazlet-strong and continue to support and embrace all those affected by this devastating event, especially the Montanaro family, we will be in a better place moving forward.

As such, please keep them in your thoughts and prayers during the days and weeks ahead. This is not an easy journey, but if we make it together, and we allow our hearts to guide us, the family will absolutely understand that they are NOT ALONE.

New Police Explorer Post

0
New Police Explorer Post

ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS –

More than a dozen members of the newly formed Police Explorer Post turned out for their monthly business meeting and heard initial instructions on what is required of an explorer, together with plans for activities within the next couple of months.

The Post meeting was held at the Shore Casino at the invitation of Casino owners with gratitude for the Police Department’s service to the community.

Ptl. Davi Cunha, the Police Explorer post advisor, welcomed the group and their parents and outlined the uniforms the Explorers will purchase to be worn for all functions.   Cunha also presented Explorer Post  caps to each of the members, a gift  from the post through a $500 donation from Sodon Electric Company.

Cunha introduced each of the officers of the post, including its two captains, Shannon Kenny and Shane O’Connor and outlined their responsibilities.

Personal Responsibility

Assisted by Detective Travis Morgan, the officers impressed on the teenagers the importance of acting every day  in a manner that brings honor to themselves, their parents, and the uniform itself. He reminded them that because of their membership they also represent the police department itself and their actions are a reflect ion on the department. He pointed out that the onlooker, seeing the badge on the post members shirt will often assume they are actual working police officers. For that reason, he explained, each shirt has EXPLORER  written in large letters on the back of the shirt.

Cunha also pointed out uniforms are only to be worn for Explorer activities and not displayed for any reason at any other time.

    Activities

Out lining upcoming activities, Cunya noted there will be a shooting competition among explorers from posts in Highlands, Middletown and the Coast Guard in April. Four members will be selected to represent this post, based on their skills at practices all will be participating in on the shooting range.

With bike trips planned for the spring, Cunya also directed members to submit their bicycle serial numbers to him for inspections and to ensure each member’s bike meets all the regulations for safety.

Middletown

The Explorers will meet with Middletown Explorers for their February meeting to continue the rapport among the local posts. A majority of members of the local post attend Henry Hudson Regional School, though it is not a requirement to live in the borough to become a member of the posts.

Kevin Aravich of Leonardo, who is one of the two lieutenants in the local post, lives in Leonardo and said while he had previously been a member of the Middletown post, he joined  this post for its proximity to his home and the ease of attending activities and meetings. Aravich, a senior at Middletown North High School, also said he has friends and relatives in the Atlantic Highland post and was motivated by their enthusiasm for the programs planned here.

O’Connor said he recognizes the added responsibilities he has as  captain of the post and feels confident he can handle it. He joined the post because he admires the department and wants to be able to learn more about things he can do to help save lives and help others.

Kenny, who joined in October, said she thinks it’s “cool” to be a Police Explorer, but joined more because of the friendships it helps her form and the opportunity to meet more people. She is excited, she said, about the scheduled practices on the shooting range.

Lt. Phil Kozic said he was motivated to join by O’Connor and is looking forward to what he will learn and the activities that are being offered.

Meetings

The Post meets twice a month, with the first meeting a business meeting and the second for training. The training meetings will take place at a variety of  locations, including the shooting range, other post’s meeting rooms, and other sport and athletic center locations.

Teens interested in joining the post can contact Ptl. Cunha at police headquarters.

Persons interested in donating to the newly formed post  can send checks made out to the Borough of Atlantic Highlands with a notation Explorers.. Checks can be mailed to the borou9gh or dropped off to Chief Reinert at headquarters..

Regionalization – Mayor Broullon Responds

0
Highlands Mayor Carolyn Broullon

Calling it “short-sighted” Highlands Mayor Carolyn Broullon had an immediate response to the reports  the Henry Hudson Regional boards of education is holding yet another meeting January 31 before taking any action on proposed regionalization with Sea Bright.

The Mayor also expressed shock that neither the Board Chair nor any board member remained silent when questioned by the audience members.

In a written statement, Mayor Broullon said

“In my opinion, it is short-sighted to leave Sea Bright out of the Regionalization plan. Including them brings cost savings to the taxpayers of Highlands and Atlantic Highlands by reducing the amount raised in taxes for the schools.  I am shocked the elected Board Members were, for the most part, silent. They have a duty to answer to the taxpayers that elected them to represent the community.”

The related Stories

Henry Hudson

Special Session

Embarrassed

Regionalization – Surprising and Embarrassing

0
Contract Superintendent
Oceanport Resident Tara Beams
Temper, Temper

It was rather surprising and certainly embarrassing to be at the Henry Hudson Board of Education meeting last night and hear Dr. Beams fly off the handle, raise the audio on her mike to a painful hearing level and say more than once “it doesn’t’ matter what Tara Beams thinks” when it comes to the regionalization issue.

She was simply asked why it appears she is so against Sea Bright being part of any planned regionalization until maybe, sometime in the future.

  Silence is Deafening

What made matters worse, was neither the board chairman nor any member of the Board of Education said a word about this $180,000 a year paid professional employee sounding like a spoiled child who can’t get her way. I can only hope they reprimand her in private and take steps to ensure taxpayers are never subjected to such antics again.

 Opposed to Sea Bright?

Of course Dr. Beams gives every sign she is opposed to Sea Bright being included. Last night she pinned the blame for all the delay on the New Jersey State Board of Education Commissioner.  If that is true, it would have been nice to hear her say she has contacted the Commissioner and asked what could be done to at least get the question on the ballot.

  The Oceanport Connection

With so many delays, and so much blame for nothing moving forward, the question does come up quite often. If it’s true Oceanport would lose a bunch of money if Sea Bright switches from there to Henry Hudson and if it’s true Dr. Beams lives in Oceanport and pays taxes there, then wouldn’t it be true also that she would have an opinion on  whether Sea Bright should be included?

Here again, the boards of education in the Henry Hudson district don’t say anything about her being the primary spokesperson on the regionalization issue. They don’t seem to think there is any conflict here. For that matter, has any board member, on any of the three boards of education, ever said anything publicly about what they know about regionalization? They defer to Dr. Beams, just as the Hudson Board Chairman did last night when I specifically directed questions to him.

 Let the Taxpayer Decide

What is so very wrong about letting the taxpayers decide whether they want to take a chance on getting more money into the towns to help cut the cost of education without cutting the quality? What is wrong with thinking the taxpayers should have the right to say what they want? If they could vote, and if they say no, no regionalization, then there’s no need for more attorneys, more mediators, more time wasted in talking about something they don’t want.

If they say yes, it sounds like a good idea and it sounds like it will save money and maybe offer more educational opportunities to the kids, then, with everyone working together, maybe the Education Commissioner would act faster if indeed that is the problem now. Maybe state legislators would push for quicker action and try to save the taxpayers some money in attorneys, delays, mediators and more studies.

 The Silent Majority

Maybe the taxpayers should get more vocal. Within the first hour after midnight last night when that first story on the Henry Hudson board meeting appeared on venividiscripto, hundreds had read the story. After midnight. By 9 a.m. this morning, several hundred more read it.

So there must be interest. There must be opinions. There must be at least some of those people who read these stories who think the public not only has the right to know, but also has the right to be heard.

It’s time to quit stalling and let regionalization for all three towns get on the ballot.

Special Session on Regionalization

0
Highlands Atlantic highlands Regionalization

The boards of Education for Highlands, Atlantic Highlands and Henry Hudson Regional School are meeting in a special session on  Tuesday, Jan. 31 to discuss what is taking place in mediation  on the question of regionalization.

 Maybe the Public is Invited

The meeting will begin at 6:30 p.m. and the boards will immediately go into executive session with their attorney to discuss the present status of the question. If the boards can come to an agreement on which way they want to proceed, they will come back into an open meeting and take action.

That was what School Superintendent Dr. Tara Beams said at last night’s meeting of the Henry Hudson Board of Education speaking for the board. In response to questions asked during the public portion of the meeting, Dr. Beams said the schools have not hired a mediator, just the two boroughs of Highlands and Atlantic Highlands have.

 Who Can Speak on the Mediator?

Dr. Beams referred questions on the mediator being appointed to discuss cost sharing between the towns should regionalization take place and referred the question to the mayors and councils of both towns, saying they are the only ones who hired a mediator.

At a meeting of the Atlantic Highlands council last week, the borough administrator referred all questions to the boards of education.

“You’re here for the children”

Former teacher and former board member Tracy Abby-White chastised the board for their inaction on the regionalization question which has been ongoing for several years and urged them to endorse having the regionalization question go on the November ballot so the residents can decide. “You’re here for the children,” she told board members, “you are here to help them get to college, get on with a better life. ” She reminded board members that the borou9gh councils “don’t tell you how to run the schools.”

Yet, she continued,  the regionalization question was put off last year waiting for a feasibility study promised in May, but not received until June. That study, she continued to point out, agreed with an earlier study commissioned by the boroughs, that regionalization with Sea Bright would be the correct way to go both for educational benefits and cost savings.  Regardless of any action on Jan. 31, Abby-White said  this  “shouldn’t end without referendum.”

“Have a Referendum”

Charles Rooney, a former Councilman in Sea Bright who has been a strong advocate of regionalization among the three boroughs and has shown at several meetings why and how it would mean considerable additional income for the two other boroughs, showed board members a newspaper from 2017 when the regionalization question statewide was a major issue and he was urged to “get in on this early and have a referendum.” Rooney has working since that time to get the question on the ballot to let the voters decide what they want.

“That’s ridiculous”

Dr. Beams told Rooney last night it is the state Board of Education that is holding up the issues and “we can’t do anything without the state board of education approval to put this on the ballot.” She said legal action and questions before the state board have not yet been resolved and that is what is holding up action locally. Rooney countered there is no legal action before the state board, just a challenge from Oceanport that Sea Bright students cannot leave the Oceanport school district  because there is no board of education in Sea Bright. “That’s ridiculous,” Rooney said, “and it would never stand up.”

Abby-White urged the school districts to leave the money issues at the municipal level and stick to their obligation to provide the education.

“It Doesn’t Matter what Tara Beams Thinks,”

When Ms Abby-White noted Dr. Beams appears to be against regionalization with Sea Bright, the superintendent went into a tirade saying several times “it doesn’t matter what Tara Beams thinks,” raising her voice and amplifying he mike. (see related story)  She said any increase in funds from regionalization with Sea Bright would not go into the budget for education, but rather would go towards the taxes paid by the taxpayers for education.

 Other Board Issues

Earlier in the meeting Business Administrator Janet Sherlock also told the board it does not appear the schools will be able to keep their tax increase under the 2 per cent allowed, due to increased costs for insurance. Worse, she said, it appears they will not be able to keep it less than two percent for two years, nor will they know before March what the tax increase would be.

During a lengthy explanation of the Start Strong Assessment results, Dr. Beams cited the areas where the results call for more attention to students primarily in the area of math, and the differences in programs between the two elementary schools in the regional district.

The Superintendent’s statistics also showed two students received one day suspensions each since December, one for insubordination to a staff member and one for being disruptive and disrespect. A third student received a four day suspension in December for confirmed substance abuse.

Henry Hudson Board of Education

0
Henry Hudson Board of Education

Thirty-three educators  from the  three schools in the Henry Hudson Regional District have either resigned or retired since Superintendent Dr. Tara Beams was hired in July 2021, a Highlands resident pointed out at the Henry Hudson Board of Education meeting last night.

While she was quick to add she is not saying there have been no improvements during the year since Dr. Beams has been here, she wondered whether there is a connection between the new superintendent being hired and the number of persons leaving all three of the schools.

Cynthia Fair, Navesink Avenue, Highlands, sat through the approximate 90 minute long meeting before presenting her statement during the public portion of the meeting, noting that 33 resignations represents approximately 20 to 25 per cent of the staff. She called on the board to investigate the “excessive attrition rate.”

While Board President Michael Gannon gave no response to Ms. Fair’s request, board member Claire Kozic rose to say “people retire all the time” and added the schools needed changes  and the fact this many have left their jobs in each of the three schools in the district, “doesn’t mean anything.”

Earlier at the same meeting, Atlantic Highlands resident Tracy Abby-White told the board “I was a teacher” before pointing out she also “sat in your seat” referring to her time as a member of the Board of Education. After listening to Dr. Beams explain her position on regionalization when at one point she put the microphone to a deafening pitch to shout “it doesn’t matter how Tara Beams feels” about regionalization, Abby-White politely told Dr. Beams   “As a taxpayer asking  a question, I would appreciate if you wouldn’t be so condescending. It’s insulting”.

Mrs. Fair said after the meeting that things were different before Dr. Beams came to Henry Hudson. As an example, she noted  her daughter’s experience before  she graduated in June, “she (Dr. Beams) never even talked to her.”

She also pointed out she has seen several instances where the superintendent was less than polite and courteous to staff members as well as the general public. The resident cited an incident when she was present at a public meeting for a holiday presentation. “I personally witnessed  Dr. Beams correcting the previous principal in front of staff and students.  “That’s just wrong, it’s discourteous.”

Comments from others after the meeting focused on Dr. Beams’ ‘body language’ during the meeting and gave as an example how she “rolled her eyes” when Mrs. Abby-White was speaking, and how she made it obvious she feels above everyone who attends a meeting. One resident  added “I’m a taxpayer, I pay her salary as a taxpayer, and she is there working for me. She has no right to talk like that. It’s simply condescending.”

Mrs. Fair presented statistics and read into the minutes the names of the eight personnel from the Atlantic Highlands Elementary School who have retired since July  of 2021 when Dr. Beams came. She then named the ten teachers at the Highlands school who also left the system in that time period as well as the 15 educators at Henry Hudson Regional School who are no longer here.

“When it comes to  a fifth to a quarter of the staff leaving, you have to wonder if there’s a specific reason,” she said.

The board did not respond to her question of “when are you going to investigate why we have such an excessive attrition rate?

Atlantic Highlands Yacht Club

0
Commodore Atlantic Highlands Yacht Club
ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS –
Growing community relationships, continuing to be stewards of the waterways  and continuing the high standards set by his predecessors are Lou  Melillo’s goal as he takes the reins from outgoing Commodore Frank Allsman of the Atlantic Highlands Yacht Club.
   This will be the second time Melillo, of Middletown, has headed the popular and prestigious Yacht Club located on the second floor of the Shore Casino at the Atlantic Highlands Yacht Harbor. He was Commodore in 2004, after serving in all the other commands from board member in the late 1990s through Rear Commodore and Vice Commodore.
   Melillo has been a member of the club since 1996 and lists numerous reasons why he joined. As a frequent and enthusiastic sail boater, he likes not only the location and activities as a club member, but also the ability to meet with other sailboat owners and other lovers of the waterways, as well as to enjoy new friendships among club members who are not boat owners. “That’s the best thing about the Atlantic Highlands Yacht Club,” he says enthusiastically, “they make us who we are as a club.”
       Since he first joined, the Commodore has always been active in Yacht Club activities. He has be chairman of the insurance committee for more than two decades, until recently passing the torch to member John Flatley. He has served on the race committee for many years and actively participates in all the club’s programs and activities.
    As a sailing enthusiast, Melillo keeps his sailboat, the Surface Tension, at the Atlantic Highlands Municipal Harbor in the same slip he has held for more than 25 years. He has cruised and raced for many years, including five Newport to Bermuda races as well as local races in Sandy Hook Bay. Currently, he owns a Beneteau First 44.7 racer/cruiser sail boat.
  Looking towards his upcoming year as Commodore, Melillo said because of their popularity and the work of all club members, all the programs in the past, including the Youth Sailing program, the annual Blessing of the Fleet, and Blue Water Regatta, Wednesday night racing, the Ms Race and other events will continue to be highlights of the seasons.
   A new activity, “Meet the Brewer” has started as a means to involve local business in club activities. The club is offering Jersey craft brews on tap and this month will have Carton Brewery from First Avenue for a Meet the Brewer event.
     A  new boating safety seminar series will be introduced this year with the Fleet Captain John DeFilippo  in charge of that event.
  While many of the racing and water-oriented events are eagerly attended by all club members, many club members are neither sailors nor boaters of any kind. They enjoy the socialization the club offers, the excellence of the galley and restaurant, as well as the cocktail hours, the bar, and other events.
  There’s no doubt the members and officers have been doing everything right, Melillo continues. Under Allsman’s leadership last year, the club had a record number of new members, boaters, sailors and landlubbers. “We’re coming off a great year helmed by Commodore Allsman,” Melillo said. “We want to continue that momentum in 2023.”
   “ Our town has grown to truly be the gem of the Bayshore, “he continued..  “The Yacht Club is just one element that makes Atlantic Highlands a “destination”.  We have transients from all over the world stopping by with nothing but praises.  It is all of our jobs to ensure we keep moving forward – one foot in front of the other – to steal an old cliche.”
  It’s a family thing as well, the commodore pointed out. Both his daughters, Tara and Victoria, grew up sailing and were there for their father’s first year as Commodore and enthusiastically supported him once again  at the gala that surrounded his taking the lead for the second time earlier this month. The new Commodore’s girlfriend, Katie, was also on hand to be supportive at the Change of Watch and is an avid sailor as well.

Clean Ocean Action – Doesn’t Give Up

0
clean ocean action cindy zipf

Anyone who knows Cindy Zipf, the Executive Director of Clean Ocean Action, knows she doesn’t give up easily, actually, never.   Her temerity and boldness have been responsible for considerably more attention ever being paid to protecting the ocean and its environs.

Following the death of seven whales in just over a month, Zipf and Clean Ocean Action immediately called for an investigation into the cause. With no apparent action taking place at the speed she feels is necessary. Zipf this week fired off a reaffirmation of her call for an investigation into  the deaths and more protection for the marine ecosystem.

    Zipf’s latest statement:

 

The death of seven whales in 39 days is unprecedented. They were all endangered species, which makes these deaths even more tragic and demands an immediate comprehensive investigative response.  What if these ocean industrial activities were related to a fossil fuel project – would that change anyone’s view on a call to action?

Why wouldn’t the 11 offshore wind-related companies be suspected? They are currently authorized to conduct pre-construction and construction activities allowing them to harm, harass, and injure as many as 63,820 marine mammals.  When has there ever been this many industrial activities permitted in the region at the same time?  Where is the evidence that these deaths are not related to the intense offshore wind sonar and other geotechnical activities?

According to the National Marine Fisheries Service these pre-construction and construction activities can cause “injury” and “disruption of behavioral patterns including migration, breathing, nursing, breeding, feeding, or sheltering.”  With such activities, there are more ships and vessels in the area which increase potential ship strikes, and sonar can deafen or disorient whales, leading them into the path of oncoming vessels.  Why shouldn’t endangered species get precautionary treatment and trigger a full investigation?

Importantly, why should offshore wind get a pass on scrutiny to ensure marine ecosystem protection, especially for endangered and protected species?  Any industrial activity – especially reckless industrial development that is massive in scope, scale, magnitude, and speed – should be required to prove it is protective of the marine ecosystem.

This is why Clean Ocean Action also continues to call for a pilot project to assess threats.  A pilot project could inform responsibly developed offshore wind, which was the promise of Governor Murphy